- 26%average CTR to the claim form
- 2origin pages for the same need
- 20%CTR from the All services page
- 34%CTR from the All digital services page
The context
An e-commerce site has a claim page, the explanatory step where the intake form starts. 2 pages lead to it. The "All services" page groups contact, warranty, delivery, returns and claims, with the "Track a claim" link placed before the "File a claim" link. The "All digital services" page only offers the claim link, with no competing link.
The claim page itself is an important step in customer service. A visitor who does not reach it ends up on the phone or in a store, which costs more and leaves a worse impression.
The finding
The CTA to the claim form had an average CTR of 26%. Decent for this type of page. But splitting by the 2 origins, the gap appeared: 20% from the "All services" page, 34% from the "All digital services" page. 2 audiences with the same stated need, 14 points of gap the average hid entirely.
The analysis
Same need, 2 CTRs
Both pages lead to the same destination with the same stated intention. Yet one converts one and a half times better than the other. The gap does not come from the claim page itself, but from the path taken before it.
Page structure
On the "All services" page, the "Track a claim" link is placed before the "File a claim" link. A visitor looking for the word "claim" finds this first link and clicks it. They land on an empty tracking page, with no file to consult, and in a significant share of cases, give up there rather than going back to find the right link.
On the "All digital services" page, only the claim link is present. Nobody gets the destination wrong.
The hypothesis
The lower CTR from the "All services" page does not come from a lack of interest in filing a claim, but from the confusion and drop-off caused by the "Track a claim" link. Reordering the 2 links should bring its CTR closer to the dedicated page's.
The change
The 2 links were swapped on the "All services" page: the "File a claim" link first, the "Track a claim" link second, both visible without scrolling. The change went straight to production, with before/after monitoring of the CTR on each origin page.
The result
The CTR from the "All services" page went from 20 to 28%. The overall CTR to the form, in turn, went from 26 to 32%.
The decision
The change was kept and the rule applied to the site's other link pairs: the most frequent action first, both options visible without scrolling when they share a close destination.
What to remember
1. An average CTR can hide a gap between segments. Always check whether the origin page changes the rate before judging an aggregated figure.
2. When 2 links share a keyword, they compete for the click. Order and visibility decide, not the label. The most frequent case goes first.
3. A low-risk change can go straight to production. Before/after monitoring on each segment is enough to confirm the effect.
Tools used
- Contentsquare for the full claim journey and click zones.
- Google Analytics for the CTR segmented by origin page and the before/after comparison.
For the full method, see the CRO and behavioural analysis expertise.